What Does Australia Think of Our Asia Pivot?

Australia_satellite_planeWhile in Australia back in February I came across the Medical Association for Prevention of War. Curious, I walked into their office and wound up in an interesting dialogue with Nancy Atkin, the Executive Officer.

I’ve been wanting to write about our conversation for some time since. It was a real treat to sit with someone so passionate about preventing war and global militarization; and Australia is on the front lines right now, due to American interests shifting to Asia – also known as “the Asia pivot.”

As US tensions continue to escalate with North Korea, Australia remains in an awkward position. In 2011, President Obama and Australian Prime Minister Julia Gillard announced an increased US presence in Oz.

“As a Pacific nation,” he vowed, “the United States will play a larger and long-term role in shaping this region and its future.” The plan he laid out includes, among other things:

  • Deployment of 2,500 US Marines to Darwin to train with Australian troops
  • Increased use of Australian air bases by US aircraft
  • A rotation of American military through Australian bases

In addition, over the last decade the US military has created partnerships with other Australian military facilities, like communications centers and training camps.

Some Australians are concerned about an integration of the two armed forces, which they fear could ultimately dilute Australia’s sovereignty.

Australian human rights organizations are also concerned that Australian involvement in US military goals could lead to a lowest common denominator situation that weakens Australia’s human rights policies.

Says Atkin, “The US military is more active, more dominant, and has less regulations on human rights. They’ve signed less treaties, use secret sites and cluster bombs. Our protocols are stringent on human rights. The pressure is to weaken our stance on a lot of these issues, which weakens the treaties.”

Australia has a history of entering overseas wars that arguably do not benefit the country much in the long run. If our Asia pivot leads to war, will they face a worse threat than necessary because of their partnership with us?

Hopefully Australia will develop a clear way to declare war in coming months, and will use it to determine whether US wars can/should be fought from their soil.

That would be what a healthy friendship looks like; and it’s to no one’s benefit that Australia do less.

One Response to “What Does Australia Think of Our Asia Pivot?”
  1. I believe, as you are painfully aware, that the US should come home and mind its own business, At the same time the US has treaty obligations with many nations most of them coming out of WWll. For example the US is a party to the ANZUS treaty with Australia and New Zealand which requires the US to defend them in case of attack. Australia came dangerously close to a Japanese invasion during WWll and only the incredible courage and blood sacrifice of a few hundred thousand US Marines backed and transported by the US Navy prevented it. Now, New Zealand no longer welcomes the US Navy to its ports. I would have abrogated the treaty the moment they did that but US leadership sees it differently. Currently the nations of India and Japan are trying to unite themselves together with the US and Australia to resist Chinese expansion in the Pacific. Can they defend themselves against an evermore agressive China? Probably not. The US, by treaty, is also obligated to come to the aid of South Korea and Japan. Perhaps these nations would be better off charting their own course without the US as skipper. That’s fine with me as I side with George Washington and oppose “entangling alliances.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

  • Copyright